ProSolvr logo

Resolve problems, permanently

Root Cause Analysis for Coriolis Mass Flow Meter Malfunction

Malfunction of Coriolis Mass Flow Meter RCA

A Coriolis mass flow meter is a highly accurate device used to measure the mass flow rate of a fluid traveling through a pipe. It operates based on the Coriolis effect, where a vibrating tube deflects as fluid flows through it. This deflection is proportional to the mass flow rate, allowing for precise measurements. These meters are crucial for maintaining efficiency, safety, and reliability in processes such as blending, custody transfer, and chemical reaction monitoring.

In petrochemical plants, Coriolis mass flow meters are widely used to measure mass flow, density, and temperature of various fluids, including crude oil, natural gas, chemicals, and liquefied gases. Despite their accuracy, these meters can encounter issues such as vibration interference from nearby equipment, erosion or corrosion of meter tubes, build-up or clogging, density measurement errors due to multiphase flow, and calibration drift over time. These problems can lead to inaccurate readings, process inefficiencies, and safety hazards if not promptly addressed.

Conducting a root cause analysis (RCA) using a fishbone diagram helps identify and resolve these issues. Categorizing potential causes under specific headings allows teams to systematically explore and address each one. Vibration interference may stem from nearby machinery, prompting corrective action to isolate the meter. Erosion might require a review of material compatibility. This structured approach ensures all possible causes are considered, leading to more effective and targeted corrective actions.

Root Causes of Coriolis Mass Flow Meter Malfunction

    • Malfunction of Coriolis Mass Flow Meter
      • Measurement Issues
        • Density fluctuations
        • Viscosity variations
        • Flow rate limitations
      • Operational Conditions
        • Process Fluid Characteristics
          • High entrained gas
          • High solid content
        • Pressure Surges
        • Extreme Temperature Variations
      • Maintenance & Calibration
        • Lack of Routine Maintenance
          • Neglecting sensor cleaning
          • Incorrect calibration procedures
          • Infrequent calibration
      • Installation & Design
        • Inadequate Design for Application
        • Pipeline Vibrations
          • Lack of proper support
          • Incorrect installation location
          • Improper meter orientation
      • Environmental Factors
        • Mechanical Shocks or Vibrations
        • Electromagnetic Interference
        • High Humidity Levels
        • Corrosive Environments
      • Material Issues
        • Material Fatigue
          • Cracking or corrosion
          • Wear and tear
        • Sensor Material Compatibility

Suggested Actions Checklist

This checklist provides a comprehensive approach to addressing potential root causes of Coriolis mass flow meter malfunctions in a petrochemical setting, ensuring a robust framework for corrective, preventive, and investigative actions.

      • Measurement Issues
        • Density Fluctuations
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Adjust the flow meter settings to compensate for density changes.
            • Recalibrate the meter to improve accuracy.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Monitor the process fluid's density regularly and adjust the system accordingly.
            • Use a density meter in conjunction with the Coriolis meter to ensure accurate measurements.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the sources of density fluctuations in the process.
            • Review historical data to identify trends and correlations with density changes.
        • Viscosity Variations
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Recalibrate the flow meter to account for changes in fluid viscosity.
            • Modify the process conditions to stabilize fluid viscosity.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Regularly monitor the viscosity of process fluids and adjust operational parameters as needed.
            • Implement a viscosity control system upstream of the flow meter.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Analyze process data to determine the causes of viscosity variations.
            • Review the material compatibility with the fluid to minimize viscosity-related issues.
        • Flow Rate Limitations
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Adjust the operating flow rate to stay within the meter's optimal range.
            • Replace the meter with one that accommodates the required flow rate.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Ensure that the flow rate remains within the recommended range through proper system design.
            • Install flow rate limiters to prevent exceeding the meter's capacity.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate incidents where flow rate exceeded the meter's design limits.
            • Review the process design to ensure it aligns with the meter's capabilities.
      • Operational Conditions
        • Process Fluid Characteristics
          • High Entrained Gas
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Install gas separators or degassers upstream of the flow meter.
              • Adjust process parameters to minimize gas entrainment.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Regularly monitor gas content in the fluid and take corrective actions if necessary.
              • Use flow meters specifically designed to handle fluids with entrained gas.
              • Perform periodic performance tests to ensure accurate readings in gas-laden flows.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate the sources of gas entrainment and their impact on measurement accuracy.
              • Review the effectiveness of current gas separation methods.
          • High Solid Content
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Clean or flush the meter to remove solid build-up.
              • Install filters or strainers upstream to remove solids.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Regularly inspect and maintain filters or strainers.
              • Monitor the solid content in the fluid and adjust process conditions accordingly.
              • Choose meter types rated for slurry or solid-laden flows when applicable.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate the process for sources of high solid content.
              • Review the compatibility of the flow meter with fluids containing solids.
        • Pressure Surges
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Install surge protectors or dampeners in the pipeline.
            • Adjust the process to minimize pressure fluctuations.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Implement a pressure monitoring system to detect and control surges.
            • Ensure proper design and maintenance of pressure control valves.
            • Design process startup/shutdown sequences to reduce sudden pressure changes.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the causes of pressure surges and their frequency.
            • Review the process control strategy for handling pressure variations.
        • Extreme Temperature Variations
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Insulate the pipeline or meter to mitigate the impact of temperature fluctuations.
            • Adjust the process temperature to stay within the meter's operating range.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Regularly monitor the process temperature and implement controls to maintain stability.
            • Use temperature-stabilizing equipment such as heat exchangers or chillers.
            • Install temperature alarms to alert operators of abnormal fluctuations.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate temperature-related incidents and their impact on meter performance.
            • Review the meter’s temperature specifications against actual operating conditions.
      • Maintenance & Calibration
        • Lack of Routine Maintenance
          • Neglecting Sensor Cleaning
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Clean the sensor and inspect for any damage or degradation.
              • Implement an immediate maintenance schedule to address neglected areas.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Develop and adhere to a strict maintenance schedule, including regular sensor cleaning.
              • Train maintenance personnel on the importance of regular sensor upkeep.
              • Use maintenance checklists to ensure all steps are followed.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate why routine maintenance was neglected.
              • Review and improve maintenance protocols.
        • Incorrect Calibration Procedures
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Recalibrate the meter using the correct procedures and standards.
            • Replace or repair any components affected by incorrect calibration.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Provide regular training on proper calibration procedures.
            • Implement a calibration schedule that aligns with operational demands.
            • Use calibration reference materials and certified standards for consistency.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate calibration records to identify errors or deviations.
            • Review and update calibration procedures based on industry best practices.
        • Infrequent Calibration
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Immediately calibrate the meter and verify accuracy.
            • Implement a catch-up calibration plan for all affected equipment.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Establish and enforce a regular calibration schedule.
            • Use automated reminders or tracking systems to ensure timely calibration.
            • Incorporate calibration requirements into equipment management software.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the causes of calibration delays.
            • Review the impact of infrequent calibration on process accuracy.
      • Installation & Design
        • Inadequate Design for Application
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Redesign or replace the meter with a model suitable for the application.
            • Adjust the process design to better match the meter’s capabilities.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Conduct thorough application assessments before meter selection.
            • Collaborate with design engineers to ensure proper meter application.
            • Utilize simulation tools to validate design assumptions.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the design selection process and identify gaps or errors.
            • Review similar installations to ensure compatibility.
        • Pipeline Vibrations
          • Lack of Proper Support
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Install proper supports and vibration dampeners to stabilize the pipeline.
              • Inspect the pipeline for any damage caused by vibrations.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Conduct a vibration analysis and implement supports during installation.
              • Regularly inspect supports and dampeners for wear or degradation.
              • Use materials and fittings designed to reduce vibration transmission.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate the sources of pipeline vibrations and their impact on the meter.
              • Review installation guidelines for adequacy in managing vibrations.
        • Incorrect Installation Location
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Relocate the meter to a more suitable location in the pipeline.
            • Modify the surrounding infrastructure to accommodate proper meter function.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Perform a site assessment to determine the optimal installation location.
            • Follow manufacturer’s guidelines for installation placement.
            • Coordinate with process engineers during installation planning.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the decision-making process for the original installation location.
            • Review the installation procedures to prevent similar issues in the future.
        • Improper Meter Orientation
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Reinstall the meter in the correct orientation as per manufacturer’s instructions.
            • Verify meter performance post-reinstallation.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Provide installation training to ensure proper meter orientation.
            • Include orientation checks in the installation verification process.
            • Develop orientation-specific inspection checkpoints in QA checklists.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate why the meter was installed incorrectly.
            • Review installation guidelines and compliance with manufacturer’s recommendations.
      • Environmental Factors
        • Mechanical Shocks or Vibrations
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Isolate the meter from sources of mechanical shocks or vibrations.
            • Reinforce meter mounting to reduce the impact of environmental factors.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Implement environmental monitoring systems to detect shocks or vibrations.
            • Design and install meters with shock-absorbing mounts.
            • Schedule regular inspections of mounting integrity.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the sources and frequencies of mechanical shocks or vibrations.
            • Review the installation and design specifications for environmental resilience.
        • Electromagnetic Interference
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Shield the meter and surrounding equipment from electromagnetic sources.
            • Relocate the meter away from high-interference areas if necessary.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Regularly test for electromagnetic interference and address potential issues.
            • Use meters designed with EMI resistance in mind.
            • Implement grounding and bonding practices to reduce EMI effects.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate incidents of EMI and their impact on meter performance.
            • Review and update installation practices to minimize exposure to interference.
        • High Humidity Levels
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Improve environmental controls to reduce humidity around the meter.
            • Inspect and replace any components affected by moisture.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Install dehumidifiers or climate control systems in high-humidity areas.
            • Use protective coatings or enclosures to shield the meter from humidity.
            • Conduct routine moisture inspections and maintenance.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the correlation between humidity levels and meter performance.
            • Review the suitability of current environmental controls.
        • Corrosive Environments
          • Corrective Actions:
            • Apply corrosion-resistant coatings to the meter and surrounding equipment.
            • Replace any corroded components immediately.
          • Preventive Actions:
            • Regularly monitor environmental conditions for corrosive elements.
            • Use materials and designs that are resistant to the identified corrosive agents.
            • Implement regular corrosion inspections and maintenance schedules.
          • Investigative Actions:
            • Investigate the sources of corrosive elements in the environment.
            • Review past incidents of corrosion and their impact on equipment performance.
      • Material Issues
        • Material Fatigue
          • Cracking or Corrosion
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Replace damaged or fatigued components immediately.
              • Perform stress analysis to determine the cause of material fatigue.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Select materials that are more resistant to fatigue and corrosion for future use.
              • Implement regular inspections to identify early signs of material degradation.
              • Apply protective coatings to vulnerable materials.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate the operating conditions that led to material fatigue.
              • Review material selection criteria for improvements.
          • Wear and Tear
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Replace worn-out components and inspect for collateral damage.
              • Adjust maintenance schedules to address wear and tear more frequently.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Use materials that are more durable and better suited to the application.
              • Implement a predictive maintenance program to monitor wear.
              • Lubricate moving parts regularly to reduce friction.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate the root causes of accelerated wear and tear.
              • Review the adequacy of the current maintenance program.
          • Sensor Material Compatibility
            • Corrective Actions:
              • Replace the sensor with one that is compatible with the process fluid and conditions.
              • Modify the process to reduce the impact on sensor material.
            • Preventive Actions:
              • Ensure that material compatibility is thoroughly evaluated during design and selection.
              • Use sensors specifically designed for the fluid characteristics.
              • Test new materials under actual process conditions before full deployment.
            • Investigative Actions:
              • Investigate previous incidents of material incompatibility and their impact on operations.
              • Review and update material compatibility assessments based on operational experience.
 

Who can learn from the Malfunction of Coriolis Mass Flow Meter template?

Root Cause Analysis (RCA) of Coriolis Mass Flow Meter Malfunction provides valuable insights for various stakeholder

  • Process Engineers: To improve process design and ensure accurate flow measurements by understanding potential issues and their causes.
  • Maintenance Technicians: To identify common problems and implement preventive maintenance strategies, reducing downtime and repair costs.
  • Quality Assurance Teams: To monitor and validate flow meter accuracy, ensuring product quality and compliance with industry standards.
  • Safety Officers: To assess risks associated with meter malfunctions and develop safety protocols to prevent accidents and hazardous situations.
  • Instrumentation Engineers: To fine-tune and calibrate the meters, ensuring their proper functioning within the plant's automation systems.
  • Operations Managers: To oversee plant efficiency and make informed decisions regarding equipment upgrades or replacements based on historical malfunction data.

Why use this template?

Using root cause analysis for Coriolis mass flow meter malfunctions offers significant benefits by systematically identifying and addressing the underlying issues causing equipment failures. RCA helps pinpoint the exact factors leading to inaccuracies, such as vibration interference or calibration drift, which might otherwise be overlooked. By employing structured methods like fishbone diagrams or the 5 Whys technique, teams can explore all potential causes and their interconnections, leading to more effective and targeted solutions. This approach not only improves the reliability and accuracy of flow measurements but also enhances overall process efficiency, reduces downtime, and minimizes maintenance costs, contributing to smoother plant operations and better product quality.

Draft and create a template for problem analysis in ProSolvr by smartQED.

Curated from community experience and public sources:

  • https://bcstgroup.com/which-are-the-common-faults-of-coriolis-mass-flow-meters
  • https://sino-inst.com/use-and-maintenance-of-coriolis-mass-flowmeters